August 2001

Volume 2, Issue 8

 

Editors:

Cherie W. Blackburn

Robert W. Pearce, Jr.

John C. McElwaine

 For more information contact

1-800-237-2000

www.nmrs.com

Nelson Mullins has more than 250 attorneys firm-wide, with over 25 attorneys having significant representation of e-commerce clients in areas including patent, copyright and trademark protection; business planning, securities and venture capital; and licensing, distribution and contract preparation. 

Atlanta Office Contacts:

Neil Grayson

neg@nmrs.com

  Lloyd Farr

lgf@nmrs.com

  Charleston Contacts:

Cherie Blackburn

cwb@nmrs.com 

Robert Pearce

rwp@nmrs.com

John McElwaine

jcm@nmrs.com 

Charlotte Contact:

Jason Sprenkle

jxs@nmrs.com 

Myrtle Beach Contact:

Franklin Daniels

fgd@nmrs.com 

Columbia Contact:

Mark Dukes

mcd@nmrs.com 

Greenville Contact:

Marvin Quattlebaum

amq@nmrs.com 

William Herlong

wdh@nmrs.com 

Munich Contact:

Stefan Lode

Lode@nmrs.de  

CyberWatch is an Internet Law Group news digest published as a service to Nelson Mullins’ clients and friends.  The articles are summaries of particular developments in the law and are not intended to be a solicitation or to render legal advice. This publication can be considered advertising under applicable laws


China Closes 2000 Cybercafes

The Chinese government has closed almost 2,000 cybercafes and ordered another 6,000 Internet cafes to suspend business and make changes.  According to Chinese officials, the move was designed to “clear up” the establishments and bring Internet use in line with regulations introduced by the Chinese Ministry of Information and Industry.  The Chinese have been worried about the psychological and physical health of children who seem to be spending too much time in Internet cafes.

AOL Botches Online Prize Contest

A computer glitch that generated false messages mistakenly told dozens and possibly hundreds of AOL users that they had each won up to $10,000.  The online contest, which was co-sponsored by Coca-Cola, involved correctly answering a question in a “POP-THE-TOP” contest and then clicking on a soda bottle icon to see if the participant had won.  In each event, the computer showed that the contestant had won $10,000. Several of the apparent winners confirmed that they had won and were assured by AOL that their prize affidavits would be in the mail within five days.  Later, however, “winning” contestants were told that instead of receiving the expected cash, they would receive a $200 gift certificate from Target and three free months of AOL.  AOL says that it has already apologized to these customers for any inconvenience and confusion.

U.S. Officials Warn Against the “Code Red” Internet Worm

U.S. government officials, including representatives from the White House and the FBI, have decided to take the unusual step of imploring organizations worldwide to protect themselves in the face of one of the largest-ever virus dangers to the Internet.  The “Code Red” worm resembles a virus and could cause widespread slow downs and sporadic outages.  Officials are frustrated that many computers are still defenseless against this attack despite a software inoculation being made available before the first attack.  Because the government relies on the Internet for everything from defense networks to financial systems, the threat from worms like “Code Red” poses a distinct danger, according to the FBI.

South Carolina Turns Computer Technicians into Child Pornography Police

Critics already have begun challenging a new South Carolina law that requires computer technicians in the state to report to police any potential child pornography on anyone’s computer.  The critics say that this law may be unenforceable and an invasion of privacy, but supporters of the law state that it is merely an extension of a current South Carolina law whereby film processors are required to report to police any child pornography found during the printing of photographs.

Organized Crime Case Raises Computer Privacy Questions

A federal court will rule soon on whether to throw out evidence gathered by a new controversial law enforcement technology system that records every key-stroke typed on an individual’s computer, including the individual’s password.  Encrypted data was taken from the computer of “Little Nicky” Scarfo who has been awaiting trial on charges of running gambling and loan sharking operations for the Gambino crime family.  The encrypted information was obtained by the FBI through use of an Internet wire tap system.  Defense lawyers are claiming that this poses a severe threat to personal privacy and sets a very serious precedent for government’s monitoring of individuals’ private files.

Movies Showing Up on Internet Even Before Release

Two weeks before its scheduled box office release, copies of the new movie “American Pie 2” were already circulating on the Internet.  Within hours of its release in theaters, copies of the new movie “Planet of the Apes” were also available on the Internet.  These pirated copies have created quite a dilemma for movie studios and also for Internet service providers (ISPs).  Studio executives believe that they are losing a great deal of revenue and want the ISPs to block the distribution of these illegally obtained copies of movies.  Studios are putting great pressure on ISPs to terminate the accounts of those found to be offering pirated movies. Movie studios estimate there are currently about a million copies of Hollywood movies available online, and they expect movie piracy to grow exponentially as high speed connections become more widely available.

MSNBC.com Releases Results of its 2000 Online Cybersex Survey

MSNBC.com, the number one Internet news site, recently released the results of its 2000 online Cybersex survey.  The survey showed that almost one in 10 respondents said that they were addicted to sex on the Internet.  The survey received more than 38,000 responses from Internet users who spent on average of three hours online each week in sexual activities.  When broken down by gender, 9.9 percent of men surveyed reported an addiction to sex on the Internet, compared to 6 percent of women.  Approximately one in four respondents acknowledged that on at least one occasion their online sexual activities had caused problems in their everyday lives.  Sixty-three percent of respondents said online sexual activities did not have a positive effect on off-line relationships.  The average age of men taking the survey was 36 and the average age of women was 32.  MSNBC.com said that the Internet attracts a young population looking for sexuality online due to its easy access, affordability and anonymity.

Annual Survey Shows Value of Brands

According to a recent annual survey carried out by Interbrand with the help of Citibank, Coca-Cola is about to lose its status as the world’s most valuable brand to Microsoft.  The survey points to a watershed event in the history of brands as the most famous brands of the old economy appear to be making way for those of the new economy.  The survey estimated that the value of the Coca-Cola name is estimated to have tumbled by 13 percent to $72.5 billion amid a gloomy analysis of Coke’s future growth prospects.  In contrast the value of new economy brands soared, with Microsoft’s value jumping 24 percent to $70.2 billion.  The survey showed that after Coca-Cola, technology companies now account for four of the world’s top five brands: Microsoft, IBM, Intel and Nokia.  The annual survey calculates the value of a brand according to estimates of its future earnings potential based on the company’s financial statements and analyst’s reports.

Software Download Patent Gets New Life

Recently the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit handed down a decision that is a set back for software makers, including Intuit and others.  In a case that began in 1995, a small New Jersey company named E-Data claimed that it had a patent that covered all downloading of software over the Internet and that it was entitled to licensing fees for all such Internet software downloads.  According to one defense attorney, if E-Data prevails in its view, “they stand to be wealthier than Microsoft.”  The appeals court recently decided that a prior ruling had too narrowly interpreted the patent.  As a result, the case has been sent back to the District Court for a new hearing.

CyberWatch by the Numbers

92%:               The percentage of Internet users who say they have surfed the Web to shop for or purchase products, according to a new report from the NPD Group.

51%:               The percentage of consumers who say they typically shop on the Web but purchase off-line.

726:                 The total of Internet-related mergers and acquisitions that occurred during the first half of 2001, according to Webmergers.

$29 Billion:     The total dollar amount of these Internet-related mergers and acquisitions during the first half of 2001.

23%:               The percentage increase by U.S. workers logging on to the Internet from their jobs for work or non-work related activities, according to a survey by Nielsen.

Nader Group Files Complaint with FTC over Web Search Engines

Commercial Alert, a three-year old group founded by consumer activist Ralph Nader, has filed a complaint with the Federal Trade Commission asking for an investigation of eight of the Internet’s largest search engines.  The group alleges violation of federal laws by selling search result top spots to the highest bidders.  The complaint asserts that many online search engines conceal the impact that special fees paid by advertisers have on search results by Internet users.  Search engines have increasingly accepted payments from businesses interested in receiving a higher ranking in certain categories or ensuring that their sites are reviewed more frequently.  The complaint alleges that the search engine’s paid listings are equivalent to television commercials masquerading as independent TV programming.

New Jersey Court Upholds Anonymity on Internet Bulletin Board

In a recent ruling, the Appellate Division of the New Jersey Superior Court held that a corporation cannot unmask the identity of an anonymous user of an Internet message board unless it can prove that it has suffered “harm” as a result of the user’s posts.  The decision prevented a corporation from discovering the true name of a “John Doe” defendant.  The court set up a four-step series of guidelines for courts to follow before forcing Internet service providers to disclose the identity of anonymous posters.  Step one requires that the plaintiff notify the anonymous posters that they are the subjects of subpoenas by posting messages on the pertinent message boards.  The guidelines include a requirement that the plaintiff identify and set forth the “exact statements purported to constitute actionable speech” and a review by the court to see if the plaintiff can show a “prima facie case” against the anonymous defendant based on evidence.

Insurer Has No Duty to Defend E-Commerce Action

In a recent decision, an Illinois state court judge held that an insurer has no duty to defend an arbitration proceeding arising from a hardware store’s use of a domain name on its Web site.  Western State Insurance Company sought a court declaration that it had no duty under a commercial general liability policy to defend the hardware store in a domain name proceeding.  The hardware store had argued that the insurer breached its duty to defend, but the court stated that it could not find that the parties intended coverage for the relief requested in the arbitration proceeding.

Eli Lilly Releases Patients’ E-Mail Addresses

Drugmaker Eli Lilly inadvertently divulged the e-mail addresses of many patients who suffer from depression, bulimia or obsessive-compulsive disorders.  An e-mail message that Eli Lilly routinely sends as a reminder about taking the company’s Prozac medicine included the e-mail addresses of all recipients.  A spokesman for Eli Lilly simply stated, “we apologize for this error.”

Internet Auction Sites Have Banner Month

In May, 2001, Internet auction sites grossed record revenues of $556 million, with eBay.com leading the pack with 64.3 percent of auction revenues.  According to this most recent survey from Nielsen, auction revenue accounted for more than 10 percent of total consumer e-commerce spending in May 2001, rising from 8 percent the previous year.  More than $6.2 million Web surfers made online purchases at auction sites in May, jumping 22 percent from $5.1 million in May 2000.

Additional CyberWatch by the Numbers

More than 20 Million: The number of Americans who have purchased airline tickets or made other travel arrangements over the Internet, according to a new study from PhoCusWright.

$14.5 Billion:              The amount of online sales booked in 2000 by the travel industry.

$40 Billion:                 The estimated amount that Americans will spend by 2003 on online travel-related purchases.

Credits: TheRegister.com; SiliconValley.com; Wired News; SiliconValley.com; NewYorkTimes.com; NewYorkTimes.com; Yahoo.com; FinancialTimes.com; WallStreetJournal.com; C-netNews.com; Newsbytes.com; Mealey’s CyberTech Litigation Report; CyberAtlas; Cnet.com.